REPLY TO THIS MESSAGE OR POST A NEW MESSAGE   

  Date  |   Subject  |   Thread

Appropriate topics

  • Archived: Mon, 16 Jul 2001 15:13:00 -0400 (EDT)
  • Date: Mon, 16 Jul 2001 14:25:26 -0400 (EDT)
  • From: Jim Creighton <jim@CreightonandCreighton.com>
  • Subject: Appropriate topics
  • X-topic: Collaboration

One reason I spent some time at the beginning talking about definitions is because the number of situations where collaboration can mean "making recommendations" is much larger than the number of situations where it is possible to "develop agreements."

In the 1970s there was a considerable effort to apply labor/management principles to resolution of environmental disputes. This worked wonderfully in a few circumstances, but had horrible results in others. Over time we learned that the labor/management analogy was not accurate and discovered that the following conditions must exist before you can talk about agreements:

1) All parties must be at the table.
2) All parties must be accepted as having a legitimate right to be at the table.
3) The constituencies must recognize the people at the table as their legitimate representatives.
4) Power needs to be somewhat equal.
5) Representatives must be able to make BINDING commitments on behalf of their constituency OR some external authority -- such as a judge -- must act as guarantor for the agreement.

What was happening was that agreements were being reached, but then new groups (or even rump groups of groups represented at the table) would spring up after the agreement and diswon the agreement, making the process of no value.

My experience is that these conditions occur rather infrequently, so that "develop recommendations" or building high levels of consensus which push the agency in a particular directions is often the more appropriate moedl.

Jim


  Date  |   Subject  |   Thread

Welcome | About this Event | Briefing Book | Join the Dialogue | Formal Comment | Search

This EPA Dialogue is managed by Information Renaissance. Messages from participants are posted on this non-EPA web site. Views expressed in this dialogue do not represent official EPA policies.